Home Boys' Lists Girls' Lists Men's Teams Women's Teams News Photos Contributors Links Help Sign-UpOnline Store
Latest News | Categories | Authors | News Archives

News & Features

Recruiting 101
Countdown: How Much Does the Coach Matter Anyway?

Sports fans typically fancy themselves to be true experts in the world of sports - even if they never even competed themselves. They love to share their opinions as to what tactics athletes should adopt, what calls the coaches should have made, who must retire, who should turn pro, who is taking performance-enhancing drugs and which coaches should lose their jobs. They love to give adulation and praise to coaches when they win - and to demonize them when they lose.

Former Oklahoma University Coach Dave Mullins
Max Landsberg, author of Mastering Coaching, states that only "20 percent of learning derives from a coach who cares about an individual's or team's learning." If this is true, then even if a coach happens to be the Michael Jordan of coaching, the most they can hope to impact a player's progress is around 20%. This means that your average or inexperienced coach may have even less than 20% influence on their players' development.

Those numbers make me question - do coaches deserve the attention they receive? My own experiences and observations have led me to believe that a team's success ultimately depends upon the quality, experience and mindset of the players within the team more than any other factor. Think about it. Do the Patriots win yet another Super Bowl without Tom Brady at the quarterback position? Do the Cleveland Cavaliers win the NBA Championship without LeBron James?

When it comes to building a successful college tennis team - or any college sports team - the most vital skill a coach can possess has nothing to do with motivation, conditioning, tactics, team-building, empathy, planning or culture building. It is, in fact, sales!

One of the reasons I retired from college coaching is because it had become clear that the profession had evolved to be more about sales and less about coaching at the highest levels. I naively entered the profession thinking it was all about tennis development and molding young students into highly functioning adults who would go take on the world. Originally, this was the sole purpose for including athletics as part of the curriculum in third-level education institutions, but I believe the relevance of this now gets lost with the influx of resources at the highest levels. Those wanting to make a name for themselves as a college coach must make recruiting their highest priority every moment of every day. At many of the elite athletic departments, winning is the number one priority. Therefore, Athletic Directors should be looking for highly skilled salespeople and investing in the development of their coaches' selling proficiency more than any other area of expertise.

The definition of the word Coach is, "One who instructs players in the fundamentals of a sport and directs team strategy." Based on this definition, I think using the word, "coach," for college coaches of all sports - including tennis - may be somewhat inaccurate. Head coaches are expected to play many different roles, and they need a term that more broadly defines their occupation. My belief is that they hold more of a management position and that coaching is just one of their various daily duties. For this reason, referring to them as managers would be more appropriate.

To be sure, there are still many dedicated "coaches" out there who are fantastic developers and phenomenal, genuine salespeople. They don't spend time negatively recruiting other programs and can connect at a high level with these teenagers. They may not be coaching championship-winning teams but they are maximizing their recruits' potential and find ways to consistently overachieve despite their limited talent level. They spend an inordinate amount of time travelling, making phone calls, and building relationships with players, parents and coaches in order to find recruits who will match their coaching style. Once those players are on campus for their freshmen years, those same coaches work hard to back up everything they promised - and work equally as hard on the court as they did during the recruitment process. I have so much respect for these coaches and what they sacrifice.

It is up to you, the future prospect, to determine who those coaches are and how important a role you want them to play in your experience. Remember that, on average, the most you can hope the coach to assist with your development is about 20%. The rest will be up to you. On the other hand, it is also important to recognize that a coach can have a negative influence on your experience, too. I coached players that were not right for my program and coaching style Even with the best of intentions, I was not the correct fit for them as a coach. This happens from time to time, so be sure to do your homework so that does not happen to you.

I tell clients I consult with all the time to get very clear on their criteria for selecting a college. Many of them will tell me that having a "good" coach is one of their top priorities. When they use the word coach, they are generally referring to the strict definition of a coach and determine how good a coach is by their win/loss record. I encourage them to challenge generally held assumptions, and that just because a coach's team wins a lot does not necessarily make him a "good" coach. It could, in fact, just make him a fantastic salesperson.

If playing for a coach who can help you develop your game is important, then you must look beyond the wins/losses and tradition of the program. There are some brilliant coaches at all the different levels of college tennis who have decided they are extremely happy in their current position - or haven't had the right opportunities to move up to higher levels and attract the top recruits. Don't overlook these coaches and programs. These coaches may be more grounded and focused on the things that truly matter in a player's tennis and personal development. They are the ones who epitomize the word "coach". They may not be bogged down in recruiting battles that require them to constantly travel and miss practices to go watch some local stud for the 87th time in the past four months. They may not put winning as their number one priority, which I know is heresy to you hard-charging, go-getter types. Understand that if Team A consistently attracts blue chip recruits and Team B has nothing but 4 star recruits, well, Team A is going to win 100% of the time, regardless of how amazing either coach is - at least in the world of college tennis.

Now, if you say your top priority is being part of a highly-ranked, championship winning team or practicing with blue chip recruits on a daily basis, well, that is a different story. I am not saying that you can't have a great coach and interact daily with a winning team of blue chip recruits, but this combination is much more rare than you think.

If having a quality coach is an important component of your college choice, then you must define exactly what characteristics you are seeking in a college coach. What are the skills you hope they possess? Is their level of success as a player important? Are you looking for someone that is going to challenge you outside your comfort zone, or do you want a coach who will be eager to appease you and is ultra-positive all of the time? Do you want a coach who has great technical expertise in order to make some changes to your game, or maybe it is someone with a background in sports psychology, or strength and conditioning. What about years of coaching experience versus a younger coach who you feel can relate better to the issues you may face as a college student? Your decision about a coach's ability should not be based on wins and losses from one year to the next, as this will change based on the team's talent level and other unforeseen circumstances. Do you like a coach because she is a good salesperson? Or do you believe she can provide exactly what it is you say you are looking for in a college coach based on something more than a few friendly conversations?

Here are some other things to consider before making your final decision: Have you watched the coach during both individual and team practices with players? Have you discussed the coach's ability with current and past players? Are many of their players improving year after year, and do these same coaches have their best seasons when they have three or four seniors on their teams who have made their way up the line-up through the years?

Maybe the tennis development aspect is not that important for you, but you want to be sure that the team chemistry is solid and the coach has a good relationship with all their players. How you are going to determine this if you have not spent some time observing interactions between the players and the coach? Whatever it is for you, figure out how you will get the answers you need to make an informed decision.

Coaches do matter, regardless of how high a priority they are to you in your decision-making process. Give enough time to research the coaches at the various teams you are considering - this decision is important enough to warrant the effort.


College Tennis Talk ...

Tomorrow, Colette Lewis of ZooTennis talks with USTA Director of Collegiate Tennis Stephen Amritraj about current and future initiatives the USTA has for college tennis. Check out that article tomorrow - as well as all the great content that Tennis Recruiting has for you in the Countdown to Signing Day!


About Wilson

Wilson Tennis is proud to sponsor the Recruiting 101 series of articles at TennisRecruiting.net.

Connect with Wilson on Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, and YouTube - or on their website.


About CrampsAWAY

CrampsAWAY is proud to sponsor the Countdown to Signing Day series of articles at TennisRecruiting.net.

What is CrampsAWAY Pro?

CrampsAWAY Pro is an all-natural, food-grade liquid supplement that can prevent or instantly stop cramps. CrampsAWAY comes in convenient single-serve packets, perfect for any athlete on-the-go. CrampsAWAY Pro is completely safe and free of any banned substances. It's also NSF Certified for Sport, so athletes can use it whenever needed, with the assurance that they are not putting anything foreign, unhealthy or illegal into their bodies.

Are any elite athletes using CrampsAWAY?

Absolutely! CrampsAWAY Pro has become the go-to cramp solution for many of the best athletes in the world; including pro sports teams in the NCAA, NFL, NBA, MLB and MLS. Also, many top ATP players use CrampsAWAY Pro as a competitive advantage, including John Isner, Jack Sock, James Blake and Tim Smyczek.

Connect with CrampsAWAY on Facebook, Instagram, Twitter, and YouTube - or on their website.


Leave a Comment


More Recruiting 101 Articles

Coachspeak: Talking Points for Recruits to College Coaches
Communication is paramount in the recruiting process. But what are the most important questions for recruits to ask during their correspondence with college coaches? We provide a list of essential talking points to find out as much as possible about a school, program and coach.

Ten Things to Know About the USTA Junior Structure Changes
Beginning in January of 2021, the USTA is making changes to its competitive junior structure. There are 10 important things to know about the changes to get everyone prepared and informed.

USTA Making Changes to Junior Competitive Structure
The USTA will be making changes to its junior competitive structure. Beginning in January of 2021, the USTA is adopting a simplified nationwide structure, which will create a standardized system and greater consistency for players, parents, coaches, tournament directors and officials.

 Recruiting 101 Index |   Subscribe


About Dave Mullins

David Mullins was a highly-regarded college tennis coach for many years at the University of Oklahoma. Mullins provides more insights into how to be prepared to play college tennis in his "How to Dominate College Tennis" Guidebook. Go to DaveMullinsTennis.com. for more information on the book - and learn about the free advice he provides as well as other services and products focused around everything you need to know about College Tennis Scholarships.
Designed for Generation Fast
Built for speed, designed for Generation Fast. The all-new Burn FST racket and Kaos shoe from Wilson are helping the future of tennis blaze a ...
See More
12/07 Erin Gray chooses La Salle
12/07 Luke McMullen chooses Salisbury
12/06 Emma King chooses Marist
12/06 Olle Wallin chooses Charlotte
12/06 Russell Willenborg chooses Salisbury
12/05 Adam Heilbronner chooses St. Lawrence
12/05 Jaden D'Abreo chooses Carnegie Mellon
12/05 Jesse McCurdy chooses Calvin
12/05 Matthew Nagel chooses Sacred Heart
12/05 Sabrina Mella chooses North Central (IL)

Full Listings: Boys' Commits & Girls' Commits


Page updated on Monday, November 04, 2019
Contact our web team with any corrections